| Name | Wins |
|---|---|
| Jon Cruz Olumide | 1 |
| Barbaro Cavernario Hechicero Soberano JR | -1 |
| Madden Mansoor MxM Collection | 1 |
| Mansoor | 1 |
| Aaron Solo | 1 |
| SHO Yoshinobu Kanemaru | 1 |
| Dutch The Righteous Vincent | 1 |
| Eric Dillinger Josh Crane | 1 |
| Love Doug Shot Through the Heart TJ Crawford | 1 |
| Preston Vance | 1 |
| Serpentico | -1 |
| Matt Taven Mike Bennett The Kingdom | 1 |
| Alex Reynolds Evil Uno | 1 |
| Ari Daivari | 1 |
| Alex Reynolds John Silver Matt Taven Mike Bennett | 1 |
| Matt Taven Mike Bennett The Kingdom | 1 |
| Alex Reynolds John Silver | 1 |
| Chris Jericho | -1 |