12th December 2024 Athena defeated via Pinfall Billie Starkz Leyla Hirsch Red Velvet in a Womens Fatal 4 Way Wrestle Dynasty International Womens Cup Qualifier Match match on Honor Club ROH with Athena getting the win over Red Velvet , match officiated by Mike Posey and commentary from Caprice Coleman, Ian Riccaboni , Bobby Cruise was the announcer # Fan Chants billie