| Name | Wins |
|---|---|
| Angelico Cole Karter Griff Garrison Serpentico | 1 |
| Kyle Fletcher | -1 |
| Boulder Bronson Jacked Jameson | 1 |
| Johnny TV | 1 |
| Evil Uno | 1 |
| Eddie Kingston | -1 |
| Anthony Henry Cole Karter Griff Garrison JD Drake | 1 |
| Anthony Henry | 1 |
| Ren Jones Trenton Tormenta Xavier Walker | 1 |
| Alex Reynolds Evil Uno John Silver | -1 |
| Peter Avalon | 1 |
| Slim J | 1 |
| Zack Clayton | 1 |
| Jeeves Kay Slim J Sonny Kiss | 1 |
| Samoa Joe | -1 |
| Shane Taylor | 1 |
| Tony Nese | 1 |
| Brian Cage | -1 |
| Josh Woods | 1 |
| Dutch Stu Grayson Vincent | -1 |
| Gates of Agony Kaun Toa Liona | -1 |
| Brian Cage Kaun The Embassy Toa Liona | -1 |
| Cody Chhun Guillermo Rosas Marcus Kross | 1 |